City of Dreams - Part 2: PR for Whom? When the Preachers of Integrity Fail Their Own Gospel
How a global PR agency that swears by fairness, transparency, and trust turned a landmark launch into a masterclass in exclusion, control, and managed optics.
In theory, public relations is about building bridges. In
practice, it's often about building walls — especially when brand image is
prioritised over public interest. The recent launch of City of Dreams Sri Lanka
was supposed to be a landmark moment for the island’s luxury and leisure
sector. What it became instead was a masterclass in how not to engage
the press — and a sobering case study in the widening gap between PR values and
PR behaviour.
The irony is especially sharp given who handled the event: a
Sri Lankan subsidiary of a major Indian PR firm that claims to stand for
fairness, transparency, and ethical leadership. On paper, this agency champions
integrity. In execution, it championed control.
The result? A tightly choreographed media event where
journalism was not welcome unless it was pre-approved, pre-dressed, and
pre-sanitised. This wasn’t an isolated lapse. It was a mirror held up to an
industry in crisis — an industry that preaches ethics while practising
exclusion.
Let’s break down the farce.
“90% Behaviour, 10% Communication” — Let’s Talk Behaviour.
The agency says behaviour is everything. So let’s examine
their behaviour at the City of Dreams launch:
• Late by five minutes? You're out.
• Freelance journalist or small media outlet? Sorry, you’re
invisible.
• Ask a tough question? Not here. Not now. Not ever.
• Try to document the media restrictions? Security might
shadow you.
If that’s “90% behaviour,” then it was behaviour built on arrogance,
exclusion, and fear of scrutiny — not professionalism.
This was less a launch, and more a lockdown. The PR team
didn’t engage the media. They managed them. Like bouncers at a nightclub, they
enforced dress codes, entry lists, and unspoken hierarchies — all while smiling
for the camera.
“We Believe in Relationships” — With Whom?
Public Relations, at its core, is about mutual respect.
About building trust between institutions and the public through the media. But
trust can’t exist without access. And at City of Dreams, access was a
privilege, not a right.
This wasn’t relationship-building. It was gatekeeping.
Certainly not with the journalists who were:
• Denied entry without clear explanation
• Barred from open dialogue or meaningful questions
• Herded like extras on a film set
• Treated not as watchdogs of the public, but as liabilities
When PR becomes a filtering system to avoid hard questions,
it stops being public relations and becomes image control. At that point, the
media isn’t reporting — it’s participating in a pantomime.
The Freelance Fallout
Let’s talk about who gets left behind in events like these:
freelancers, independent journalists, and small digital media houses.
In an age where mainstream newsrooms are shrinking and
independent voices are rising, freelancers are often on the front lines of
meaningful journalism. Yet, they were systematically excluded from this event —
not due to lack of professionalism, but simply because they didn’t carry the
“right badge.”
This trend is toxic. It shrinks the diversity of voices and
perspectives. It ensures only the most “manageable” outlets are invited — the
ones less likely to rock the boat. And it sends a clear message: access isn’t
about credibility, it’s about compliance.
In the long run, this does more than hurt journalism. It
hurts the public. Because when access is controlled, truth becomes optional.
“We Don’t Work With Gambling or Alcohol” — But We’ll Build
the Illusion Around It
The agency proudly claims they don’t represent gambling or alcohol
brands.
Fair enough. But they seemed more than happy to handle the
launch of a resort with a luxury casino at its heart.
Let’s not be naive. The entire City of Dreams launch was a
glitzy celebration of gambling culture — wrapped in velvet and polished with
champagne.
• Branded poker chips in the media packs
• Carefully curated casino tours for “select” media
• No transparency on gaming operations — only glossy showrooms
• A clear attempt to market lifestyle indulgence without
naming what it truly is
Maybe the agency didn’t technically represent the
casino component. But they managed the optics. They sold the illusion. And in
doing so, they profited from the very industries they claim to avoid.
Ethics isn’t about loopholes. It’s about consistency. You
can’t preach purpose and profit from pretense.
“We Practice What We Preach” — Then Preach Something Else.
The phrase “we practice what we preach” only works
when the practice matches the sermon.
If your idea of transparency means pre-screening journalists
and staging interactions, you’re not practicing transparency.
If your idea of fairness means filtering out smaller media
and dodging tough questions, you’re not practicing fairness.
And if your defense is: “that was the client’s choice,” then
you’ve already failed. Because ethical PR isn’t just about doing what the
client wants. It’s about knowing when to push back — and when to walk away.
But here? The standard was not ethics. The standard was
convenience.
When Ethics Become Optics
All of this would be laughable if it weren’t so depressingly
real — and so perfectly timed.
Because this PR debacle unfolded just as the Public
Relations Association of Sri Lanka launched its long-awaited PR Code of Ethics —
a document meant to promote transparency, trust, and professionalism in
an industry desperately in need of it.
A milestone moment for the profession?
Absolutely. But here’s the punchline: The leader of Sri
Lanka operations for the very Indian PR giant behind this launch was not just a
member of the association — he was its founding and first president.
Let that irony settle in.
The very individual who once helped write the ethical
rulebook presided over an event that violated almost every principle in it.
So what does that say about the rulebook? What does that say
about leadership? And most of all — what does that say about accountability?
When ethics become a branding exercise, not a professional
compass, they lose all weight. They become decorative. Meaningless. A press
release about ethics is not ethics. A launch speech about trust is not trust.
And if this is what ethics looks like at the top, what
message does that send to the rest of the industry?
Performative Integrity and the PR Illusion
Too many agencies today treat ethics as something to signal,
not to live. Codes of conduct are adopted for LinkedIn posts and awards
ceremonies — not as daily principles. And in fast-growing markets like Sri
Lanka, where media literacy is still finding its footing, the danger is even
greater.
Without accountability, these codes become camouflage — a
way to appear responsible while continuing to operate with impunity.
So let’s stop applauding firms for publishing ethics.
Start watching how they behave when those ethics are inconvenient.
The PR Industry Needs a Reckoning — And It Starts With
Accountability
Let’s be clear: this is not about one launch event. This is
about the rot that’s spreading across the PR industry — where the goal is no
longer to inform, but to protect. Where the job of PR is no longer to build
trust, but to manage optics.
And when agencies that claim to lead the industry become
participants in this rot, the danger multiplies. Because they validate the
culture. They train the next generation. And they decide what the new normal
looks like.
If they truly believe in values — now would be a good time
to prove it.
Start with an apology. Then start doing better.
A Final Note to the PR Industry
Don’t tell us about your values. Don’t show us your mission
statements. Don’t flash your awards and your slogans.
Show us in how you treat the press. Show us in how you
handle criticism. Show us when nobody’s watching — and when everybody is.
You say PR is about behaviour? Then behave like it.
Because reputation is not built through control. It’s earned — by integrity.
