Who Watches the Watchdog? Why Sri Lanka Needs a Real Media Regulator

Because self-regulation without teeth is just PR in a press badge

In any functioning democracy, the media is meant to hold power to account.


But in Sri Lanka, the media itself has become a kind of untouchable power bloc — one that makes plenty of noise about ethics and freedom, while quietly ensuring no one ever holds it accountable.


We call it self-regulation.


But let’s be honest — it’s self-preservation in a suit.


And now more than ever, we need to ask:


Who’s watching the watchdog?


Because right now?


No one with power. No one with independence. And certainly no one the public can trust.


What We Have Isn’t Regulation — It’s Reputation Management


Let’s start with the Press Complaints Commission of Sri Lanka (PCCSL) — the go-to name dropped anytime media ethics come under scrutiny.


 Yes, it resolves complaints.


Yes, it promotes a Code of Practice.


Yes, it holds “dialogues” and “sensitisation workshops.”


But here’s the real story:


•          It has no legal authority to compel correction or enforce discipline.
•          It functions on voluntary membership — meaning media houses can opt in or out at their convenience.
•          And most critically, it is funded and governed by the very industry it’s supposed to regulate.


That’s right: the watchdog lives in the house, eats from the same bowl, and answers to the same master.


How can the public trust a regulatory body when:


•          Its board includes powerful publishers, editors, and industry insiders?
•          Its budget is supported by the same media houses that commit ethical violations?
•          Its leadership rotates between those who owe their careers to the institutions they're supposed to scrutinise?


Let’s be blunt:


When the regulator is funded by those it’s meant to regulate — you don’t have a watchdog. You have a PR firm.


The Performance of Accountability


When media fails — and it does, regularly — what happens?

•          A slanderous article goes viral.
•          A community is defamed by a sensationalised story.
•          A paid article runs unlabelled, fooling readers into thinking it’s real news.
•          A public figure’s life is upended by a lazy hit piece.


And then?


•          An apology might appear — hidden, euphemistic, and days too late.
•          A quiet internal meeting is held.
•          The journalist is blamed, then promoted elsewhere.


What never happens:


•          Public transparency.
•          Independent investigation.
•          Proactive correction.
•          Institutional accountability.


We have an entire ecosystem designed to look like it’s listening — while doing everything it can to avoid being held responsible.


When “Self-Regulation” Becomes Self-Protection


Many media leaders in Sri Lanka love to say:


“We don’t need government control. We regulate ourselves.”


But what they really mean is:


“We’ve built a cosy club where no one asks uncomfortable questions.”


•          No conflict of interest declarations.
•          No transparent audits of editorial integrity.
•          No oversight over political affiliations or advertiser interference.
•          No independent recourse for journalists facing internal censorship or retaliation.


And when someone outside the industry dares to critique the press?


They’re met with indignation, deflection, or the ultimate Sri Lankan rebuttal:


“Aren’t you attacking media freedom?”


No.


We’re asking for media accountability — the thing that gives freedom its meaning.


What Sri Lanka Actually Needs: A Real, Independent Media Ethics Body


This isn’t a call for government control. We’ve seen what state regulation looks like — and no one wants a return to censorship boards and phone-call journalism.


But what we do need is something the public can believe in.


An independent media regulator must:


•          Be funded independently — through a public fund, not media house donations or industry sponsorship.
•          Have legal protection, but zero editorial interference from state or commercial interests.
•          Include journalists, ethicists, civil society reps, and the public — not just industry insiders.


 Have the power to:


•          Conduct ethics reviews.
•          Recommend and publish disciplinary findings.
•          Call out institutional failures.
•          Protect whistleblowers inside newsrooms.
•          Demand transparent corrections and disclosures.


This is not about “punishing” the media.


This is about building real credibility — from the inside out.


The Hypocrisy That’s Killing Trust


Let’s remember:


•          The same editors who spike stories for ad clients sit on ethics panels.
•          The same outlets that run planted stories host media awards.
•          The same institutions that preach independence quietly take cheques from telecoms, banks, and ministries.


The Sri Lankan public is not stupid.


They see the bias.

They feel the silence.

They know when a story has been watered down, neutered, or spiked.


And they know that the “watchdog” is just there to bark when it’s safe — and sleep when it’s not.


Final Word: Don’t Fear Accountability — Fear What Happens Without It


Media freedom is essential. But freedom without accountability becomes licence.


And licence, unchecked, becomes decay.


If we truly care about journalism in Sri Lanka:


•          We must build a regulator that serves the people — not the publishers.
•          We must fund ethical oversight with independence — not industry favour.
•          We must stop protecting reputations and start protecting public interest.


Because if the public no longer trusts the media,


And the media refuses to clean its own house,


Then the watchdog becomes the problem — not the solution.


 Sri Lanka doesn’t need another press statement.


It needs a regulator that can finally say, “Enough.”